Toddler hitting: what we tried when the phase got physical

The first hit I remember came on a Thursday in April, at 4:20pm. The toddler wanted up, and I had the baby in my arms. “In a minute,” I said. She hit my leg, twice, then went limp on the floor, arms up, like a tiny protest made of gravity. Hitting is normal, which helped us not at all in the moment. So here is what we tried, what made it worse, and the three moves that finally ended it.

The hits came with the baby

The hitting started when the baby came home, aimed at the parent whose lap was taken. That was me, most days: I held the baby and said no to everything fun. The toddler was 21 months old and had opinions she could not say yet. The Zero to Three guide puts aggressive behavior at its peak around age two. It names a new baby as a major change that can make a toddler feel insecure. That matched our flat exactly.

The hits showed up at feeds and at “no”, at the end of anything she enjoyed. The partner got a share, while the baby never did. That line held from day one.

We were deep in that first month: the carrying phase, ten minutes of one-on-one, the witching-hour split. The structure was there. The words were not. Hitting was her vocabulary for “the lap is taken” and “you are not listening”. The month the baby arrived rewired her whole world, and the hits were the static.

What we tried first, and why it fed the phase

Lectures and big reactions made the hits more interesting. Our worst week, the fourteen-hit one, came at the end of the lecture era. We did the classic rounds first.

The worst moment was my fault. At 9:12pm, a hit landed on my face and my glasses hit the floor. I shouted. She cried. That was the week I started counting. The count did not flatter me, since the peak came right after my loudest reaction. The pattern was embarrassing to read back. Most of our toddler problems are a scheduling or tiredness problem wearing a costume. This one had a costume I helped make; the terrible-twos logic still applied.

The block-name-move system

Three boring moves, in the same order, ended the phase faster than any lecture we tried.

Block. An open hand between the hit and me. One sentence, said once: “I won’t let you hit me.” No grabbing, no gasping; the sentence was enough. The American Academy of Pediatrics says young children have little natural self-control. They need to be taught, calmly, not to hit when angry.

Name. Then the feeling sentence: “You are angry because the lap is taken.”

The hit was a word she did not have. We gave her the word, then repeated it until she took it.

Move. “Push here.” The wall, the sofa cushion; hands get a job, feet get a job. The AAP suggests offering an acceptable alternative. Zero to Three suggests ways to manage strong emotions, like hitting a sofa cushion on purpose.

When the storm passed, we did the repair: a pat on the spot, one quiet sorry, then we moved on. No lecture at the end. The lecture was the thing that had fed the phase.

One more rule had no moves at all: the one time her hand swung toward the baby, I caught it. The baby is the one rule with no exceptions. Gravity did the rest.

My instinct was to talk the whole thing through. The partner’s instinct was to block and stay boring. The log settled it: boring cut the numbers in half within two weeks. She was right. I told her so after the third week, which is a sentence I do not write often.

• Block the hit with an open hand, one calm sentence
• Name the feeling out loud
• Give the hands a job: push, squeeze, stomp
• Repair with a pat and one sorry, then move on
• Count the hits weekly, and read the trend, not the day

The same block-and-name logic showed up again in the mine phase, where it worked too. By then the toddler could say “my turn” instead of grabbing. The words arrive late, but they arrive.

The hit log

The log proved the system was working before we believed it. Every Sunday at the kitchen table, I wrote down the week’s count and what had happened right before each hit. The chart below is the whole series, six weeks in spring 2026.

The system started in week three. The peak was week two, which was also the loudest. Not a coincidence. Once the reaction went boring, the numbers fell on their own. The falling numbers made us boring-er, which is not a word, yet it is the whole mechanism.

The week kita started, the column was empty for the first time. We stopped counting.

The teeth phase came later, at kita, needing its own system: the flat-response system for biting. Same boring logic, different body part. The hitting system stayed home, where the hits had happened.

When the hitting is not a phase

Some hitting is a flag, not a phase. The AAP’s aggressive-behavior guide names the flags: hitting that stays aggressive for weeks, attacks on adults, or injuries to others. Zero to Three adds unprovoked hits out of the blue, plus aggression that keeps interfering with play and learning. Our pediatrician said it shorter at a checkup: keep the response boring; call us if it does not fade. It faded.

One thing we never had to solve: the animal version, since our flat has no pets. Parent forums describe a whole separate campaign against dogs and cats. I am glad we never ran it.

Filed under toddler. Everything we’ve written is in the archive. Our accuracy and sourcing rules live on the editorial policy page.